Keeping the People Who Keep Campuses Running

Retaining professional staff could be a college’s competitive advantage

For years, colleges and universities have invested heavily in recruiting world-class faculty and visionary presidents. Far less attention has been paid to another workforce challenge unfolding behind the scenes: retaining the professional staff who guide students from application to graduation.

Across the country, institutions are struggling to keep academic advisors, financial aid counselors, registrars, information technology professionals, residence life staff, admissions counselors, and other student support specialists. Their departure is becoming more than a human resources issue. Increasingly, it is an enrollment, student success, and institutional competitiveness issue.

These employees often serve as students’ first and most frequent point of contact with an institution. They answer financial aid questions, troubleshoot technology problems, coordinate housing assignments, maintain academic records, provide career guidance, and help students navigate personal and academic challenges. When those positions remain vacant or experience constant turnover, the effects ripple across nearly every aspect of campus life.

According to the College and University Professional Association for Human Resources (CUPA-HR), voluntary turnover among higher education employees rose sharply following the COVID-19 pandemic before gradually declining. Although turnover rates have moderated, they remain elevated in several employee groups compared with pre-pandemic levels, particularly among nonexempt and part-time staff, continuing to strain institutions already operating with lean workforces.

The Consequences for Student Success

Professional staff may work behind the scenes, but their impact on student success is highly visible.

An academic advisor with an overwhelming caseload may not have time to proactively reach someone who is struggling. A financial aid office experiencing staffing shortages can take longer to process awards or answer questions from families trying to make enrollment decisions. Residence life departments with unfilled positions often ask current staff to shoulder additional responsibilities, increasing the likelihood of burnout and further turnover. These operational challenges ultimately become student experience challenges.

As colleges compete for a shrinking pool of traditional-age students, every interaction matters. Students increasingly expect timely communication, accessible services, and personalized support throughout their educational journey. Delays in admissions processing, registration, financial aid, advising, or housing can influence whether or not prospective students enroll and if current students persist to graduation.

Research has consistently shown that advising, student engagement, and support services play a significant role in student retention. Maintaining experienced professional staff in these areas is becoming an essential component of institutional success.

Why Employees Are Leaving

Compensation remains one of the most frequently cited reasons employees leave higher education, but it is far from the only one.

CUPA-HR’s 2025 Higher Education Employee Retention Survey found that nearly one-quarter of nonfaculty employees indicated they were likely to seek another position within the following year. Beyond salary, respondents identified workload, limited opportunities for advancement, workplace flexibility, organizational culture, leadership, and not feeling valued as significant factors influencing their decision.

The survey also found that those who reported stronger connections to their institution’s mission and greater confidence in leadership were substantially more likely to remain.

Gallup’s workplace research reaches similar conclusions across industries. Employees who feel engaged, supported by their managers, and connected to meaningful work are significantly less likely to leave their organizations. They have consistently identified managers as one of the strongest influencers on employee engagement and retention.

Many higher education staffers also describe what has become known as “responsibility creep.” As positions remain vacant because of budget constraints or hiring challenges, those remaining frequently absorb additional responsibilities without corresponding increases in support or compensation. Over time, the result can be chronic burnout, declining morale, and additional departures.

Admissions offices illustrate how quickly staffing challenges can affect institutional performance.

According to CUPA-HR, 71% of admissions coordinators and counselors have been in their current positions for three years or less, reflecting significant turnover in one of the most student-facing functions. These professionals are responsible for cultivating relationships with prospective students and families while serving as the institution’s public face throughout the recruitment process.

Frequent turnover means campuses continually invest time and resources in recruiting and training new employees while losing experienced professionals who possess valuable institutional knowledge and relationships. Retaining experienced enrollment professionals may prove just as important as recruiting the next incoming class.

The staffing challenge extends well beyond student affairs offices.

Information technology personnel remain among the most sought-after employees across every sector of the economy, leaving colleges and universities competing with private companies that often offer substantially higher salaries and greater workplace flexibility.

At the same time, technology has become inseparable from the student experience. Learning management systems, cybersecurity, AI usage, digital accessibility, registration systems, and classroom technology all depend on highly skilled professionals.

Student Affairs Administrators in Higher Education (NASPA) identified cybersecurity and AI governance among the most pressing issues facing student affairs leaders in 2025, underscoring how essential experienced technology professionals have become to institutional resilience.

Leading Institutions Are Rethinking Retention

Forward-looking institutions are beginning to recognize that employee retention is not simply an HR responsibility but a strategic investment.

For example, Towson University has worked to strengthen retention by emphasizing workforce planning, improving onboarding practices, expanding professional development opportunities, and creating clearer career pathways for difficult-to-fill positions. Rather than treating turnover as inevitable, university leadership has framed retention as an operational priority that protects institutional knowledge and improves organizational effectiveness.

Across higher education, similar approaches are gaining momentum. Colleges are reevaluating compensation structures, expanding hybrid work options for eligible positions, investing in supervisor training, recognizing and rewarding employee achievements, and creating more intentional opportunities for career advancement.

These efforts reflect a growing understanding that investing in their current workforce is more cost-effective than repeatedly recruiting, hiring, and training replacements.

Higher education has spent decades discussing faculty recruitment and retention as a strategic priority. However, overlooking staff is missing half the picture.

For years, many institutions viewed these employees primarily as an operational expense. That assumption is becoming increasingly difficult to defend. The institutions that successfully recruit, develop, and retain exceptional staff are discovering that the people who keep campuses running are also the people who help them thrive.

Other News