The People Behind Admissions Decisions

Inside Georgia Tech’s system for training application reviewers, managing a growing volume, controlling bias, and protecting consistency.

At Georgia Tech, an admissions officer who reviews college applications may evaluate 40 in one day, spending only six to nine minutes on each during the first stage of the cycle. The reader may be a longtime admissions professional or a part-time employee hired for the six-month application review season. No particular degree or professional background is required.

Those details might sound unsettling to students who have spent years building their academic records, writing the perfect essays, and participating in multiple activities, all in an effort to put forth their best reflection of themselves. Each application may be opened four or five times as it moves through the initial review, secondary evaluation, and, in some cases, a final round led by experienced staff, according to Mary Tipton Woolley, executive director of undergraduate admission at Georgia Tech.

This system addresses a challenge facing selective institutions nationwide. How can an admissions office process an enormous volume of applications while ensuring that hurried evaluations, uneven levels of experience, or individual biases do not determine who gets in and who doesn’t?

This question is growing more urgent. During the 2025-26 admissions cycle, more than 1.5 million students submitted nearly 10.8 million applications through Common App. Total volume rose 6% from the previous year, according to Common App’s end-of-season report.

The workforce evaluating those submissions is notably young and mobile. The College and University Professional Association for Human Resources (CUPA-HR) found that 71% of admissions coordinators and counselors had been in their positions for three years or less, compared with 53% of higher education professionals overall. Their median time in the job was two years. CUPA-HR concluded that institutions have long relied on relatively young employees in high-turnover positions to perform much of the work of building an incoming class.

Who Reads the Admissions Application?

Georgia Tech’s undergraduate admissions office would include approximately 35 employees if fully staffed, Woolley says. About 11 or 12 focus exclusively on the review of first-year applications. Other staff members handle transfer applications, recruitment, dual enrollment, and admissions operations.

That permanent team is not large enough to process the application volume alone. Georgia Tech also hires more than 40 part-time readers, who typically join the office for around six months. For those positions, Woolley says, the university is less concerned with a specific degree or career path than with whether someone can absorb a wide range of information, analyze it quickly, and make a sound judgment.

“You have to be able to review a broad swath of information, take that information, distill it pretty quickly, and then make a decision about what you’re reading,” she says.

The use of seasonal readers raises important governance questions across higher education. Institutions must decide what authority those employees receive, how their work is monitored, whether experienced readers review their conclusions, and how consistently they apply institutional priorities. At Georgia Tech, initial review may involve readers across experience levels, but later reviews and final decisions are assigned to experienced staff.

Training That “Never Ends”

Before new full-time employees and part-time readers evaluate applications independently, they complete approximately 20 hours of asynchronous coursework through an online learning platform. That preparation is followed by live training and a process Georgia Tech calls “norming.” During norming, those with three or fewer years of experience sit alongside veteran staff members and evaluate applications together. They discuss course titles, school programs, activity abbreviations, essays, and the ratings assigned to subjective portions of an application.

“We want everybody to be sort of normed in the same direction,” Woolley says.

Every subjective rating is connected to a rubric, which the university reviews annually. Admissions leaders also consult campus partners because information gathered during the application review may later influence scholarship or specialized program evaluations.

Training continues after readers begin working independently. Supervisors examine rating patterns throughout the admissions cycle and look for employees whose assessments consistently fall outside the group’s norms. Admissions professionals sometimes refer to someone as a “hard reader” or a “lighter reader.” Georgia Tech tries to identify those tendencies before they produce systemic differences in how students are evaluated.

Woolley, who has worked in admissions for approximately 26 years, says experience provides an important form of knowledge. A veteran reader may be familiar with a particular high school, recognize its course offerings, or know the broader community surrounding it. New employees bring a different kind of value. Their questions require experienced staff members to explain practices that may have become automatic.

“When you have to explain how to do something, there’s so much opportunity for refining the work that you’re doing,” Woolley says.

One File, Multiple Reviews

Georgia Tech describes its process as both selective and holistic. The university considers academic preparation, community contributions, college major selection, essays, recommendations, standardized tests, and, for some international students, interviews. The university says the process is intended to identify innovative thinkers and problem-solvers while ensuring it enrolls students from varied backgrounds and across academic disciplines.

Holistic review, however, does not mean every factor carries equal weight at every stage. The first pass focuses primarily on academic preparation. Readers consider the courses available at a student’s high school, whether the student pursued an appropriately rigorous curriculum, and the grades earned. If the applicant appears academically competitive, the reader examines the more subjective aspects of the file, including activities, essays, interests, and potential fit at Georgia Tech.

A second, more experienced reader then reviews those sections and determines whether the initial evaluations and ratings are appropriate. That additional step is designed to prevent one individual’s preferences or assumptions from carrying too much weight. Rubrics and second reads can reduce inconsistency, but they cannot make a subjective process fully objective.

In some cases, a third review is necessary. Woolley offered a hypothetical example: If the office has 1,000 remaining offers but has identified 1,200 qualified candidates, experienced readers must determine which students receive those offers.

For the 2026 first-year class, Georgia Tech admitted more than 8,700 students and expected approximately 4,100 to enroll. The university received a record 68,000 applications according to their Office of Undergraduate Admission.

Context, Not Checklists

The brief review window makes contextual knowledge especially important. Georgia Tech does not allow applicants to upload a résumé, so students must compress their activities into Common App’s limited fields. Readers must understand those constraints rather than equating brevity with a lack of accomplishment.

The office also trains readers to evaluate writing for insight, not technical perfection. “We’re not grading an essay like a teacher would,” Woolley says. “We’re not going to go through it and look for comma splices or misspellings.” Instead, an essay should help the reader understand who the applicant is and how that student might fit in at Georgia Tech. The university’s published guidance says strong essays demonstrate authenticity and self-awareness, deepen its understanding of the applicant, and respond thoughtfully to the prompt.

Context is also central to reducing bias. Readers are taught to set aside personal affinities, including the instinct to favor an activity because they participated in it themselves. More importantly, they are asked to consider what opportunities were available to a student and how the student took advantage of them.

Research experience, for example, may be impressive, but many applicants live in communities where high school research opportunities are scarce or nonexistent. The same principle applies to advanced courses, extracurricular activities, leadership roles, and paid or unpaid jobs. Without contextual review, a reader can mistake access for achievement, privilege for initiative, or an unfamiliar experience for a less valuable one.

AI’s Emerging Role

Artificial intelligence is beginning to reshape both sides of the application process. Georgia Tech tells applicants they may use AI as an assistant. Appropriate ways could include identifying colleges that fit their goals, condensing an activity description to meet Common App’s limits, or providing feedback on an essay idea. The distinction, Woolley says, is whether AI assists the student or actually replaces their authorship.

Within admissions offices, AI could handle more mechanical tasks, including counting college-level courses, recalculating grade-point averages, and identifying coursework milestones on transcripts. “That’s actually something AI can do well if it’s well trained,” Woolley says.

Automating those tasks could give readers more time to consider fit, personal context, and other human dimensions of an application. It also creates a new quality control responsibility. Institutions must ensure that automated systems interpret transcripts accurately across different schools, grading systems, course names, languages, and document formats before the resulting information affects a review.

The National Association for College Admission Counseling has reported that colleges are exploring AI for transcript assessment, GPA recalculation, applicant communication, and staff training. The organization has also highlighted concerns about privacy, transparency, and embedded bias.

For Georgia Tech, Woolley says, the goal is not to transfer decision-making to a machine. It is to remove administrative tasks that do not require human judgment.

“It’s not trying to take the place of the human,” she says. “It lets the humans spend more time on the more humanistic parts of the application.”

Selective admission may never be fully objective because it is not intended to be mechanical. The institutional obligation, then, is not to eliminate judgment. It is to ensure that judgment is trained, tested, reviewed, and never allowed to rest with one person alone.

Other News