Students Know More About Their Favorite Content Creator Than Their University President

Creator culture has changed how a new generation recognizes authenticity, builds familiarity, and decides who deserves its attention. Higher education leaders may not need to become influencers, but they can no longer ignore what students have learned to expect from the people behind the institutions they trust.

Ask a college student about their favorite content creator and you may get more information than you bargained for. They know where that person grew up. They know if they have a sense of humor. They know what they think about the latest controversy, what their morning routine looks like, and probably what they ordered at a restaurant three Tuesdays ago. They recognize the creator’s voice before seeing their face. They understand the inside jokes. And when a new video from them drops, there is a good chance they will see it before the day is over.

Now ask that same student about their university president. The conversation might get considerably shorter.

That comparison is intentionally provocative. There is no national study establishing that students know more about creators than their college’s president, and university leaders have responsibilities that bear little resemblance to those of professional content creators. Presidents oversee sprawling institutions, navigate budgets and boards, raise money, manage crises, and represent constituencies whose interests do not always align. Nobody needs or wants to watch a president’s “Get ready with me for a Board of Trustees meeting” reel.

But the comparison points to a serious shift in communication. Today’s traditional college student grew up in an information era where personality and information increasingly arrive in the same package. Pew Research Center found that social media use is especially widespread among younger adults. In its 2024 report on Americans’ social media habits, 78% of adults ages 18 to 29 said they have used Instagram and 62% have used TikTok. Nearly three-quarters of adults under 30 used at least five of the social platforms Pew measured.

That doesn’t mean every young adult follows influencers, nor does social media use automatically translate into trust. It does mean, however, that many of today’s students have spent years experiencing communication in environments built around individual voices. Creators speak directly into cameras. They respond to comments. They tell stories. They explain complicated subjects conversationally. Their audiences see them repeatedly, hear their opinions, and gradually develop a sense of familiarity with people they may never meet.

Colleges traditionally communicate very differently. The language is polished. The logo is prominent. The statement has been approved. The email usually begins with “Dear campus community.” There are good reasons for that caution. Higher education communicates about issues ranging from public safety and financial aid to political controversy and crises. Accuracy, consistency, and institutional credibility matter. But somewhere between the press release and the perfectly polished presidential portrait, higher education faces a question that creator culture has made increasingly difficult to avoid.

Can People Feel Connected to Leadership They Rarely See?

This question comes during a broader crisis of institutional trust. The 2025 Edelman Trust Barometer, based on more than 33,000 respondents across 28 countries, found widespread grievance toward major institutions and argued that rebuilding trust requires leaders to understand stakeholders’ realities, address their concerns, and invest in communities.

Higher education has its own version of that challenge. Colleges are asking students and families to make one of the largest financial and personal investments of their lives at the same time that questions about affordability, value, and access have become increasingly difficult to ignore. Gallup and Lumina Foundation’s research on the state of higher education illustrates the tension: Americans continue to see substantial value in postsecondary education even as concerns about cost threaten access and confidence in the system.

Communication cannot manufacture trust, but it can help determine whether an institution feels like a distant bureaucracy or a community of recognizable people. And that is where creators may have something to teach college presidents.

Creators did not invent authenticity, community, or storytelling. What they have done is build an entire communication ecosystem around them. The most successful ones interact with audiences regularly, rather than only when they have something important to announce. But they show up consistently. They develop recognizable voices. They invite audiences into conversations rather than simply broadcasting information at them. Over time, those repeated interactions create familiarity.

For higher education, that distinction matters. A president who appears only in commencement speeches, fundraising announcements, crisis statements, or the occasional campuswide email may be highly effective at the job and still remain largely abstract and unknown to students. The title is familiar but the person holding it may not be.

Creator culture flips that relationship. The individual often becomes familiar first. Their work, organization, product, or message follows. That doesn’t mean university leaders should copy the conventions of influencer culture wholesale. A college president performing TikTok dances in the quad simply because TikTok is popular is not authentic. If anything, students accustomed to consuming enormous amounts of online content may be particularly skilled at recognizing when an institution is trying too hard.

The more useful lesson is simpler: People connect with other people.

That idea is hardly foreign to higher education. The National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE) has spent decades examining what students actually derive from their college experiences, and its research has repeatedly explored the importance of relationships in student engagement. NSSE’s annual research is designed to help institutions understand how students spend their time and what they gain from college, including the role relationships play in the quality of undergraduate education.

Those relationships are usually discussed in terms of students’ interactions with faculty members, advisers, peers, and other members of the campus community. But the creator economy raises an adjacent question for institutional leadership: What does it communicate when the people making some of the college’s most consequential decisions remain largely invisible to those affected by them?

Visibility alone is not engagement. A president can post online every day and still appear inaccessible. An institution can produce beautifully edited videos that reveal very little. A social media strategy can generate millions of impressions without creating a single meaningful relationship. The difference lies in whether communication creates a sense that there is an actual person on the other side of the screen.

That’s one reason student-generated storytelling has become increasingly valuable to colleges and universities. Student ambassadors and campus creators can show prospective and current students dimensions of college life that an admissions brochure cannot easily capture: the walk between classes, the dining hall everyone talks about, the professor whose class fills immediately, the quiet corner of campus nobody tells first-year students about. The appeal is not necessarily higher production value. Often, it is the opposite. The content works because the person delivering the message has experienced the thing they are describing.

That same principle can apply to leadership. A president doesn’t need to document breakfast or turn every meeting into content. But students should hear directly from the person making decisions. They should see them walking through campus, talking with students, explaining why a difficult decision was made, celebrating faculty work, acknowledging when the institution gets something wrong, or simply demonstrating an understanding of what campus life feels like beyond the administration building. The distinction is subtle but important.

Being Visible Is Not the Same as Becoming an Influencer

Recognition can matter when an institution needs students to listen. During a crisis, colleges often ask their communities to trust messages from leaders who students may have had little to no interaction with. When tuition rises, programs close, protests erupt, policies change, or tragedy strikes, an email from the president suddenly carries enormous weight. Trust built through communication is cumulative. The mundane posts, ordinary conversations, explanations, celebrations, and moments of accessibility create context for the difficult messages that inevitably come later.

This is also where higher education has to resist the temptation to reduce authenticity to a communications tactic. Students are unlikely to trust a president simply because someone in marketing convinced them to start filming vertical video. Authenticity without substance is just branding. If leaders invite conversation but never listen, visibility accomplishes very little. If students see a president constantly online but cannot identify meaningful ways their concerns reach decision-makers, accessibility becomes performance. And if institutional messaging adopts the language of community without students experiencing community themselves, the gap between the brand and reality may become even more obvious.

Creator culture may have changed the language of connection, but it did not change the requirement that connection needs to be earned.

The challenge for colleges, then, is not figuring out how to turn presidents into creators. It is understanding why creator culture has become so effective at making audiences feel connected in the first place.

Higher education is already experimenting with some of those lessons. Student ambassadors, social media takeovers, podcasts, short-form video, behind-the-scenes content, and student-generated storytelling have given institutions ways to communicate beyond traditional marketing. The Council for Advancement and Support of Education (CASE), whose resources and research focus extensively on advancement and institutional communications, has documented a communications landscape in which colleges increasingly have to navigate changing platforms, audience expectations, and approaches to engagement.

Technology is accelerating that shift. The 2025 EDUCAUSE Horizon Report describes higher education being reshaped by technological and social change, including evolving expectations surrounding teaching, learning, and digital experiences. For institutions, adapting is not simply a matter of adopting the newest platform. It requires understanding how technology has changed the behaviors and expectations students bring with them to campus.

That distinction is important. Creators themselves offer a cautionary tale. Familiarity can build trust, but it can also create the illusion of intimacy. Popularity is not expertise, and engagement is not credibility. A leader’s most-viewed post is not necessarily their most important contribution to an institution.

Higher education should not trade one imperfect communication model for another. Instead, colleges can borrow selectively from what creator culture gets right: consistency, recognizable voices, storytelling, responsiveness, accessibility, and the willingness to communicate like a person rather than a logo.

The real lesson of creator culture is not that everyone needs to become an influencer. It is that people pay attention to people they recognize.

Other News