Classes meet. Students register. Committees convene. Reports are submitted. From the outside, the institution appears intact. Inside, however, faculty and staff may still be carrying the effects of layoffs, abrupt leadership or policy changes, public controversies, chronic understaffing, workplace conflict, or decisions that leave people feeling ignored or betrayed. Employees become guarded and departments retreat into silos. People stop raising concerns because they no longer believe speaking up will change anything. The institution moves forward, but it does not heal.
Higher education leaders often respond to these periods by focusing on recovery. They announce a new strategic plan, reorganize a division, hold a retreat, or introduce additional wellness resources. Those actions may help stabilize operations, but stabilization and healing are not the same. Recovery asks how an institution can resume its work. Healing asks what happened to the people doing that work, what relationships were damaged, and what must change to prevent the same harm from recurring.
That distinction requires leaders to approach institutional well-being as a structural responsibility, not simply a collection of benefits or individual coping strategies. A healthy institution is not one in which employees have access to meditation sessions while continuing to work within systems marked by mistrust, inequity, or unresolved conflict. It’s one capable of recognizing harm, accepting responsibility, restoring agency, repairing relationships, and changing the conditions that produced the harm.
Acknowledge What Happened
Healing begins with an honest account of what the institution has experienced. After a period of upheaval, leaders are often eager to turn the page. They may worry that revisiting painful decisions will deepen division, invite criticism, or undermine confidence. Employees, however, rarely experience silence as neutrality. When leaders refuse to acknowledge a difficult period, the people affected by it may conclude that their experiences are being minimized or erased.
Acknowledgment does not require leaders to agree with every interpretation of an event. It requires them to recognize that something consequential occurred and that people experienced it differently. For example, a new president arriving after a contentious previous administration might acknowledge that repeated leadership turnover damaged trust. A dean overseeing a merger might recognize that employees are grieving the loss of professional identities and relationships, even if the merger is necessary. A department chair might admit that a conflict was allowed to continue for too long and affected their entire team.
The language must be specific. General statements about “challenging times” can sound evasive and empty when employees have experienced layoffs, discrimination, threats, or institutional neglect. Leaders should explain what they understand happened, what remains unresolved, and what responsibility the institution accepts. They should also make clear that acknowledgment is the beginning of a process, not a substitute for action.
Build a Place for Harm to Be Addressed
Institutions have procedures for reporting misconduct. Far fewer have processes for addressing harm that does not fit neatly into a formal complaint. A policy can determine whether a rule was violated. It may not repair a working relationship, rebuild trust within a department, or help a community process the effects of an incident.
Restorative practices offer another approach. Instead of beginning solely with the question of who violated a policy and what punishment should follow, restorative processes ask who was affected, what they need, who is responsible, and what repair is possible.
The University of Pennsylvania has developed a campuswide restorative practices program serving students, faculty, and staff. Restorative Practices at Penn provides facilitated processes for healing and accountability along with consultations, workshops, and community-building circles. More than 75 trained practitioners across the university help departments, programs, and campus groups respond to conflict and strengthen relationships before harm occurs. The program’s premise is that accountability should require more than assigning blame. The person or group responsible for harm must understand its effects and participate in meaningful repair, while the people affected must have agency in determining what healing requires.
At Duke University’s Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, faculty and staff participated in restorative justice training designed for workplace use. They subsequently incorporated restorative approaches into advising, team building, training, and workplace culture initiatives.
These practices can help institutions address incidents that conventional solutions often leave unresolved: a department fractured by a contentious search, colleagues harmed by discriminatory behavior, or employees who no longer trust leadership after decisions are made without their participation. Restorative work should not replace formal investigations when safety, discrimination, harassment, or legal rights are at issue. It can, however, address the relational damage that a formal finding alone may not reveal.
Return Agency to the People Affected
Institutions frequently attempt to help communities heal by designing solutions for them. Leaders assemble a task force, select programming, approve a new initiative, and then invite employees to participate. Even well-intentioned efforts can reproduce the dynamic that contributed to the original harm: consequential decisions are made elsewhere, and the people most affected are asked to adapt to whatever is offered to them.
A healing structure does not merely collect feedback. It gives people meaningful influence over what happens next. That may mean allowing employees affected by a reorganization to help redesign workflows or giving a department experiencing conflict a role in selecting a facilitator and defining the goals of the process. It may mean compensating faculty and staff whose lived experience or institutional knowledge is essential to the repair work. The distinction is between consultation and shared agency. Consultation asks, “What do you think of the plan?” Shared agency asks, “What needs to change, and how will we decide together?”
Carnegie Mellon University describes restorative practice through a similar principle: People are more likely to make constructive changes when institutions do things with them, rather than to them or for them. Its restorative practices initiative creates opportunities for community members to address harm, develop shared understanding, and work collaboratively toward accountability.
Leaders retain responsibility for decisions that belong to their roles. Shared agency does not require every choice to be made by consensus. It does require leaders to identify where community members have actual decision-making power and to be honest about where their authority ends. Nothing erodes trust faster than asking people to participate in a process where the outcome has already been decided.
Repair Material Conditions
Listening is necessary, but doing so without material change can become another injury. If employees describe unsustainable workloads, healing may require eliminating responsibilities, filling vacant positions, or changing deadlines. If a review identifies pay inequities, repair may require compensation adjustments. The response must connect to the harm.
Material repair may require leaders to make uncomfortable choices about budgets, authority, workload, and accountability. It may also reveal that some familiar institutional practices are no longer defensible.
Leaders should report what they heard, what will change, who is responsible for transformation, and when the community can expect progress. When a requested change is not possible, they should explain why and identify what can be done instead. The goal is not to promise that every problem will be solved. It is to demonstrate that telling the truth about institutional conditions produces a meaningful response.
Rebuild Relationships Before the Next Crisis
The University of Pennsylvania’s program includes community-building work intended to strengthen groups before a serious rupture occurs. Virginia Tech has also trained campus leaders in restorative approaches that can be applied to teams working through strained relationships, limited resources, and conflict.
These efforts recognize that healthy relationships are a crucial part of institutional infrastructure. A department whose members know how to raise concerns, navigate disagreement, and repair smaller harms is better prepared for a major disruption. A leadership team that has already established honest communication is less likely to lose credibility when difficult decisions arise.
Relationship building does not need to involve forced vulnerability or artificial team-building exercises. It can begin with routine practices that make people feel recognized and included: discussing how a team wants to handle conflict, creating space to raise concerns before decisions are final, checking how workloads are distributed, and acknowledging contributions that often remain invisible.
Measure Trust, Not Just Morale
Colleges commonly measure employee engagement, job satisfaction, or participation in wellness programs. Those data may not reveal whether the organization is healing. A department can report relatively high job satisfaction while employees remain afraid to disagree with leadership. Staff members can participate enthusiastically in community events while believing that institutional processes are unfair. Employees can appreciate their immediate colleagues while having little trust in senior administration.
Leaders should examine whether people believe they can raise concerns without retaliation, decision-making is perceived as fair, acknowledged problems lead to action, and employees have meaningful influence over the conditions of their work.
Qualitative evidence is essential. Listening sessions, facilitated conversations, confidential interviews, and open-ended survey responses can show where trust is returning and harm remains unresolved. Institutions should pay particular attention to differences across roles and identities. Senior faculty members, adjunct instructors, frontline staff members, and employees from historically marginalized groups may experience the same institution very differently.
Leaders must also close the loop. Asking employees to recount difficult experiences without reporting what was learned or what will change can reinforce the belief that their participation is merely symbolic.









