About 13% of U.S. undergraduates failed their college’s “satisfactory academic progress” (SAP) requirements in spring 2025, and just over half of them lost federal financial aid the following term, according to a new national evaluation from Mathematica, funded by the Lumina Foundation.
SAP rules require students to keep a minimum GPA, complete enough of the courses they attempt, and finish within 150% of a program’s published length to keep receiving federal aid. The report says it provides the first national estimate of how many students fall short. It puts the number at about 1.8 million credential-seeking undergraduates, and says roughly 970,000 lost aid eligibility. Mathematica’s dashboard lists the share of failing students who lose aid at 54%.
Who Is Affected
Failure rates were highest at two-year colleges (22%), versus 8% at public four-year institutions and 5% at private four-year institutions. The sample included too few for-profit colleges to estimate their rate. Pace of progress, which most often requires students to complete 67% of attempted credits, and GPA were the most common sticking points at 5.6% and 5.4% of students nationally. The maximum time frame requirement accounted for 2.7%.
Financial aid administrators most often named low-income, first-generation and first-year students as those who struggle. The dashboard shows 36.7% of institutions (weighted by enrollment) cited low-income students and the same share cited first-generation students, while 29.1% cited first-year students. The administrators said academic effort was often not the main issue. They pointed to life circumstances affecting attendance (91.5%), health challenges (85.3%) and time management (60.3%), along with a lack of information about how the rules work.
Appeals and Policy Choices
All institutions in the study allowed appeals, but only about one-quarter of students who failed filed one. About three-quarters of those who appealed kept their aid, which suggests many students may lose it without understanding the process.
Most schools have not adopted optional, more lenient policies. About one-quarter of students attend colleges with a “laddered” GPA requirement that starts more leniently, and only about one in 10 attend a college with a similar pace requirement. About two in three attend institutions that count developmental, or remedial, courses toward the maximum time limit, though those courses do not count toward a degree. Administrators cited pressure to match peers and the staffing burden of revising complex policies as barriers. Some institutions deliberately choose stricter rules, in part to encourage students unlikely to succeed in the short term to leave before taking on more loans.
State policy plays a role too. California passed a law in 2023 barring SAP requirements stricter than the federal minimum, while Texas’s largest grant program demands a higher GPA than the federal standard, which may encourage stricter rules at institutions there.
Recommendations
The authors recommend that colleges communicate rules earlier, in more than one format, and reach students before they fail, since websites and email have limits and students reported “email fatigue.” They also call for better coordination between financial aid and advising staff. The report notes, for example, that advisers may encourage students to withdraw from courses to protect their GPA without realizing withdrawals can count against them under pace-of-progress rules.
The authors caution that more research is needed to show which reforms improve graduation and employment outcomes.









