Backers of Maryland’s UMES Sue State for $6 Billion, Alleging 136 Years of Discriminatory Underfunding

A group of students, faculty and alumni backing the University of Maryland Eastern Shore (UMES) has sued Maryland officials, alleging the state has deliberately underfunded the historically Black land-grant university since 1890. The plaintiffs are seeking $6 billion and structural changes to how the school is funded and governed.

The amended complaint was filed Oct. 26 in U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland. The plaintiffs are ForUMES, a nonprofit corporation made up of UMES students, faculty, alumni and prospective applicants, along with two current students, Chad Lance and Andre Cooper. The defendants include Gov. Wes Moore, the state’s interim higher education secretary and the Maryland Higher Education Commission chair. They also include the University System of Maryland’s board chair and chancellor. Moore and the others are named in both their official and individual capacities.

The Allegations

The complaint traces the dispute to the Second Morrill Act of 1890, which tied new federal land-grant funding to either admitting Black students or creating a comparable institution for them. The University of Maryland, College Park did not admit Black students until after a 1950 lawsuit. The suit alleges that Maryland designated the small Princess Anne Academy, which became UMES, as its land-grant college for Black students while directing most of the money to College Park.

UMES, the plaintiffs say, “was supposed to be a separate but equal Land-grant college.” Instead, they call it “a woefully underfunded stepchild of the University System of Maryland,” and say “Maryland deliberately underfunded UMES.” The complaint claims the disparity continued through the 20th century.

The suit brings three counts: one under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act and two under the Equal Protection Clause. Beyond damages, the plaintiffs want the court to require equitable allocation of future federal land-grant and state matching funds, adequate funding for capital projects, and the ability for UMES to appoint its own leadership under a board independent of the Regents. They demand a jury trial. Higher Ed Dive noted the plaintiffs do not explain how they arrived at the $6 billion figure.

Earlier Federal Scrutiny and Recent State Gains

In 2023, Biden administration education and agriculture secretaries wrote to Moore that “The longstanding and ongoing underinvestment in University of Maryland Eastern Shore disadvantages the students, faculty, and community that the institution serves.” They calculated a $321.2 million shortfall over the prior 30 years, while acknowledging that the state budget “has taken steps to address this historic underinvestment.”

Since 2023, UMES has received about $9 million a year in added state funding under a 2021 law that settled a lawsuit by HBCU supporters. State funding per full-time student rose from $19,640 in fiscal 2022 to more than $26,000 in each of the next three years, Maryland Matters reported. The university system’s Board of Regents approved nearly $15 million in April for the campus’s planned veterinary school, set to open in June 2027. Enrollment was 3,177 in fall 2024, up 10.1% in five years.

Other News