Building International Student Belonging and Success Alongside Compliance

International students are perhaps the most compliant population on our campus. They are doing great by every measure the Office of International Student and Scholar Services (ISSS) tracks. New international students show up at the mandatory orientation, complete all forms, and file all required visa paperwork.

Ling G. LeBeau, PhD

And yet, semester after semester, I hear they eat alone, no one invites them anywhere, faculty do not make eye contact with them in class, and they feel invisible in the institution that has documented every step of their arrival. We certainly have built robust systems to track where our international students are and what they are doing, but we do not have a system to notice how they are doing and what they might need from us.

Currently, the compliance work managed by ISSS is more complex and critical than ever. International educators are under extreme pressure to keep apprised of immigration regulations and policies and to verify that their international students maintain visa status through the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS). A missed deadline or an incomplete form can jeopardize a student’s status to stay in the U.S. Educators are exhausted and stressed.

None of this argues against this work. It argues against letting compliance work become the primary focus for higher education institutions that enroll international students.

Institutions naturally invest limited resources when the stakes are visible and the metrics are clear. Belonging has no dashboard to defend it. When international educators are stretched thin managing federal regulations and policies, they don’t have time or energy to build relational work with international students. It’s not because they stop caring, but because nothing forces it back onto the agenda and staffing and resources are shrinking.

These students often arrive in the U.S. expecting ISSS to feel like a home away from home. Given the diminished support provided to ISSS and the mounting demands from regulations, educators have limited time and energy to create programs to help students with educational and cultural transitions. As such, many feel lonelier than they ever imagined, and some begin to question why they came abroad at all.

The cost of this phenomenon falls on students quietly and invisibly. For some of them, our office becomes synonymous with paperwork and authority, not support. When a crisis does arrive, such as a family emergency, a mental health struggle, a moment of isolation, or failing academic performance, some international students feel lost and do not know who to reach out to.

Integrating Compliance and Belonging

Building belonging and success alongside compliance does not require abandoning either. They should not be siloed, but integrated. It requires an intentional and holistic approach with a few deliberate shifts.

The person who reminds a student about visa paperwork does not have to be the only one who ever reaches out to them. Relational check-ins often land better from someone outside the ISSS that holds authority over a student’s status. We can build touchpoints that have nothing to do with paperwork at all: a check-in that asks how a student is doing and not whether their documents are current sends its own message about what the relationship is for.

Belonging cannot be ISSS’s job to prove. It must be distributed across faculty who notice an empty seat in class, resident advisers who observe a quiet or withdrawn student resident, or peer mentors who see a student eating alone, all signals that compliance systems were never built to see. The communication and peer mentoring pillars of the International Student Success model were built around exactly this distribution: regular, personable outreach that exists independent of any deadline. Structured peer relationships give students a connection point that compliance was never designed to offer.

None of this is expensive. Most of it is just time and attention, not money. The forms will still need to be filed. The deadlines will still need to be met. But an institution can both protect a student’s legal status and still make sure that they know, long before any crisis, that we are glad they came to our campus.

Not every international student does, and they shouldn’t have to wait a month or a semester or find their way to the right office before someone notices. That is not a compliance problem. It is a belonging problem, and it is ours to solve.


Ling G. LeBeau, PhD, is director of international student success at Syracuse University and a member of the Insight Into Academia Editorial Board.

Other News